A Seattle resident tasked with selling two pocket watches for an estate is seeking a trustworthy appraisal before accepting an offer. The first unresolved question is whether the watches are solid gold or gold-plated. Online image searches and eBay comparisons have turned up similar-looking watches priced anywhere from tens of dollars to thousands, without establishing what these particular pieces might fetch.

Trust is a concern because of previous experiences with precious-metal buyers. The seller reports visiting three businesses and receiving quotes that differed by several multiples. With the watches belonging to an estate rather than to the seller personally, the concern is accepting too little for someone else's property.

The immediate goal is a rough estimate of what the watches could sell for, though an outright sale would also be welcome at an acceptable price. For this estate sale, useful questions to bring to an appraiser include whether the cases are gold or gold-plated, what supports the valuation, and whether any figure offered is an estimated selling price or an offer to buy. Those distinctions would give the seller a clearer basis for comparing offers than appearance alone.